Ask HN: Are tech layoffs happening abroad?

Ask HN: Are tech layoffs happening abroad?

I can just promote the UK, however the tech market is really various here. We do not actually have big tech business like in the United States. The majority of tech operate in the UK remains in sectors like financing, retail, or public sector. While our economy isn’t terrific and there are lay offs it would be incorrect to call it “tech layoffs”.

We have some tech start-ups here too however, and those are certainly having a hard time today, however start-ups do not generally lay individuals off, they merely stop working, which takes place all the time anyhow.

Where it is like the United States is in the method tech hiring has actually dropped off a cliff. If you’re working at a start-up and the start-up stops working, or if you’re a professional and your agreement isn’t restored then you’re going to discover it very difficult to discover work right now. I’m getting a great deal of messages from ex-colleagues at the minute having a hard time to discover work however thinking of it I do not understand anybody who really got laid off unless you’re speaking about long-lasting agreements not being restored.

The only sector that appears totally great is public sector work, however there’s simply inadequate public sector work to walk around.

> We do not truly have big tech business like in the United States.

No, however you do have the governemnt, HFT and banking market which pays professionals well, plus regional branches of numerous leading United States business which is still an upper hand on the labor market comapred to many EU memebers, meanign wages on top end are much greater than the majority of the EU.

Try to find tasks in nations without leading banking and no branhces of leading United States business and see what incomes resemble. UK will appear like a paradise.

It’s bad in Europe. Spotify let great deals of individuals go in 2015, Pitch just recently fired 2/3 of their personnel. Glovo, Veriff, Xolo are simply a couple of others I became aware of, however I’m sure it’s a hell of a lot more.

I’m believing when this correction has actually settled we’re most likely entrusted business that produce real worth rather of simply buzz, which is great, and I ‘d rather work for business with genuine revenues anyhow, however it’s rough to ride this wave today for sure, specifically if you get laid off and require to pay expenses.

Japan: It’s extremely tough for business to lay off workers here, and I have not seen any reports of big layoffs in the Japanese service press. A lot of IT work is farmed out to smaller sized business, and lowerings in subcontracting may not make the news. Work lowerings by smaller sized IT companies may fall under the media radar, too.

The photo of the general work scenario as communicated by the news media here is of a tight labor market and of trouble for business in finding and maintaining workers.

Germany: as a senior the marketplace looks ok, although a bit slower and clients appear more reluctant to begin pricey projects/hire extra specialists. I get a couple of task provides from time to time, enough to not be jobless long if I wanted/had to change my company.

According to Bitkom, the German IT trade association, there are 149,000 open IT positions reported in Germany since 2023-12-13, which is 12,000 more than one year back.[1] The absolut numbers are not so considerable here, due to the fact that this is just what is reported and a great deal of IT positions exist beyond the IT market in the narrow sense, however the pattern is rather significant.

[1] Source: https://www.bitkom.org/Presse/Presseinformation/Rekord-Fachk … (in German)

As somebody who had a hard time discovering a task in 2015 I had a look at news release and I discovered precisely what I believed I would discover: 61% of business state that the candidates’ income expectations “do not match the business’s recognized wage structure”, 35% of them see bad German language abilities as a trouble, and 48% are putting their hopes on AI to resolve the proficient employees’ lack.

To my negative eyes this appears like “we desire experienced employees, we desire them to speak proficient German, and we desire them low-cost”. And as the stating goes, you can select 2 of those things however seldom all 3.

Freelance designer from Germany here. There is a substantial drop in tasks and a downturn in irreversible offerings, however no layoff wave like in the United States. Need is still high however due to the existing economic downturn most business postpone employing in the meantime.

From my viewpoint there is likewise a skill-missmatch in Germany. While companies search for the typical most modern-day tech stacks, labor force is frequently conservative, remaining years or perhaps years at one business with out-of-date innovation. Employing non-EU residents is nearly difficult since of the administration.

In Germany the scenario is made complex and various from the United States.

The majority of the remote tasks I see from Germany likewise work with just those who reside in Germany, so it appears to me that Germans do not even desire EU residents, simply Germans.

That’s in every EU nation for tax and social security factors, they desire you to likewise be a tax homeowner there since that dicatates your tax, labor laws and staff member advantages indicating it’s familiar and foreseeable for the business.

There’s no EU broad citizenship, worker guidelines and tax liability for staff members however are regional for each nation. They do not desire you generating income in one nation however spemding it and taxing it in another.

This is where the EU is weaker than the United States and will keep fizzling in software application.

You pay earnings tax based on where you live. I can make cash from Germany, however if I live in Estonia, my taxes go to Estonia. A lot of remote employees I understand are established as LLC’s, and they merely invoice their customers for the work, totally preventing any tax or social security problems for the company, given that you the staff member need to handle it yourself in your own nation.

Initially you pay taxes in the nation the business you work for is signed up (there may be b2b alternatives, which may vary). You pay rest in the nation where you have a tax residency.

In your example, in the beginning you pay taxes in Germany and if Estonian taxes are larger, you pay the distinction there.

I am partially working for an Italian business from Germany. Billing is really basic. I invoice the Italian business according to the so-called reverse charge treatment: My billing does not consist of VAT, however just the European VAT variety of my and the client’s business. The consumer should settle the VAT with his tax workplace. I just need to notify my tax workplace at routine periods about the turnover with the specific business, so that the European tax authorities can examine whether the consumer has actually stated his taxes properly.

I invoice through my own business. This is not necessary. You can likewise obtain a VAT number as a private and follow the very same treatment. I did this before I established the business.

A minimum of in Germany there are stringent guidelines for what is called a pretence of self-employment. A freelancer requires to have more than one customer, the customer can not set working hours, access to systems likewise can not be the exact same when it comes to workers and so on. United States has something comparable AFAIK, I would anticipate most EU nations to have it too.

Well yes, EU/Europe is a collection of numerous independent nations, unlike U.S which is one nation. And you can’t operate in a nation as a staff member without having a house authorization because nation. The contrast to U.S here makes definitely no sense.

> The contrast to U.S here makes definitely no sense.

Why not? My ex German employer relocated to the United States to work for a business there and given that the position is remote, he can live and operate in any state he desires. You can’t do that in the EU which restricts labor movement which harms the EU economy and development versus the United States.

United States is one nation. European Union is not a nation, it is a collection of lots of independent nations with different laws, languages, cultures, federal governments. You can likewise live and work from any corner of the very same nation in EU if you desire, supplied that your task is likewise in the exact same nation, similar to in the U.S. This is not any various.

What you’re stating resembles can you work for a Canadian business while residing in the U.S? Or an Argentinian business while residing in the U.S? I do not believe so. I stop working to see how U.S is in some way much better here, and you’re comparing European Union to 1 nation, which is simply absurd, given that EU is not a nation. European Union “states” are not the like U.S states. They are real nations.

I never ever stated the EU is a nation (nor does it require to be to meet my point), however as a financial block, if it wants to comepete with the United States in regards to economy and development, it requires to do much better in regards to labor movement, and the present status quo is holding it back.

I hope my point of what I initially indicated is clear now and you do not require to discuss any longer about why the EU is not a nation like the United States.

There are guidelines to handle this. Lots of French individuals near the border work in Belgium. They are even actively hired.

Yeah, however those guidelines remain in location primarily to accomodate cross border commuters. I can’t quickly be used by a Belgian comapny while living and operating in Portugal like those residing in Belgium, however includes additional hoops like either me working as a LLC or the business establishing a workplace in Portugal or employing me through a regional Porthughese 3rd party, adn most caompnies do not desire this trouble simply for one worker.

I’m not in Portugal, that was simply for the sake of an example.

Numerous supervisors I was familiar with have a difficult time revealing themselves in English correctly.

They fear miscommunication and the administrative work linked to non-German staff members.

This is efficiently ineffective as you require to send your staff members one by one to get this exception. I understand of a company ($ 4bn earnings) who stated this is merely not practical.

EU bureaucrats are simply dumb.

> Hiring non-EU people is nearly difficult due to the fact that of the administration.

We wish to thin down the currently average earnings much more? If you can’t discover employees throughout the entire 448 million EU block going to work for you, you’re doing something incorrect.

What makes you believe that designers from Brazil, Vietnam, Canada, Egypt or the United States would require a lot lower earnings? I assisted business onboarding individuals from all over the world, and every designer (a minimum of those we satisfied and signed) understand their worth.

Due to the fact that if individuals can complete on incomes due to lower COL, they will, and some business will reward that.

> and every designer (a minimum of those we fulfilled and signed) understand their worth

What about those you didn’t sign? What about the SW bodyshops aka visa stores, who hope on desperate immigrants from damaged nations attempting to emigrate at any expense? I understand more of those sleezy bodyshops than I have fingers on my hands to count.

I never ever stated your comapny does this, however you can’t pretend migration wage disposing does not exist which lots of companyes aren’t exploiting it.

You likewise can’t inform me with a straight face that flooding the marketplace with more employees does not lower earnings according to the supply/demand of the marketplace.

These immigrants will rapidly discover the expense of living in Germany and what their associates get, I do not believe it’s a considerable aspect. What actually keeps earnings down IMO is the absence of high-margin/high-growth services, absence of German “unicorns”, basic risk-averseness of German capital (which can be discussed by the previous 2).

> IMO is the absence of high-margin/high-growth companies

It’s not actually a German-only thing. Besides the United States and China practically no other nation presently has such things. EU is mainly standard companies and risk-averse financiers.

I’m likewise a freelance designer living in Germany. I’ve been fortunate enough to be on a relatively big, continuous task for the in 2015, so I have not been impacted. Brand-new job inquiries/leads have actually generally dropped to zero for me.

From work, to real estate, it seems like the population remains in “wait and see” mode.

What is the administration in concern? Needed wage for the blue card is actually low now, particularly for tech employees, so generally you simply proceed and employ as I comprehend.

You can obviously employ a professional and tax them as typical company expenses. For an irreversible position the staff member requires a European Social ID, a Tax ID, health care account and a bank account. All this is required before you can pay the staff member’s very first loan.

As soon as you register your address, you get your tax ID and social ID. You open a bank account and register for an health insurance coverage. Is this the administration you are discussing?

Keep in mind that we likewise had actually COVID and moved to remote gigs in Germany. This suggests that we take on individuals situated in smaller sized cities and even towns which most likely have a respectable pay rate bump.

I have not heard much this year in New Zealand however ’21/ ’22 was quite bad for Xero and a handful of smaller sized business. Total business here didn’t see the outrageous 2020 development of American companies. Hiring has actually slowed throughout the board, extremely.

Yeah I would state the very same thing. Slower working with general however less huge layoffs. I’m a professional and have not had much of a lack in work for a while now, however we did have a huge agreement drop off in 2022 when the business went through a double-digit layoff.

Have not heard much from my household in Japan. Layoffs are unusual in Japan in basic and joblessness is normally constantly in the 2% variety there. I’m sure start-ups are having a hard time there though as that appears to be the international pattern, however the software application engineers I understand there at larger business have not discussed anything about layoffs and appear to be doing fine.

Heard that S. Korea tech scene remains in a comparable circumstance. It’s much more difficult to do mass layoff in the nation, however lots of people are leaving their business in a kind of “voluntary. resignation”. Employing downturn is occurring as well as task cancellation.

No layoffs amongst the (tech or otherwise) loved ones I understand in the Germany/Netherlands/Belgium location

We are becoming aware of tech layoffs in a few of the biggest “tech” business, however I’m not exactly sure that we’re seeing that in the numerous business where tech serves the requirements of business.

In France I didn’t heard a great deal of layoff. It’s just recently way harder to discover a excellent task, however you can still discover a shitty task over night at seeking advice from business

I understand the response is “since neolibs,” however I believe a minimum of one political leader may wish to project a little on how business are changing United States staff members with low-cost labor abroad. I do not even require to take a side on the matter. Objectively it appears they’re faltering rather hard.

Find out more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *